While zoom is active a left drag moves the box and never selects or moves a layer beneath
it (creator ruling 2026-11-01). MouseMove already owned the zoom drag; the missing guard was
in MouseLeftButtonDown, which happily hit-tested a layer first and left a stray selection
plus a half-started drag behind the moving box.
Creation holds Ctrl (Ctrl+right-click), and Windows repeats a held modifier. The repeat
tick landed after the box existed, so the dismiss handler saw an open box and closed it:
appear, then vanish ~500ms later. Guarded with e.IsRepeat, which only ever skips the
repeat events — a genuine second press still closes the box.
Two creator directives, 2026-11-01.
**Ctrl-down dismisses an open zoom box.** Window-level PreviewKeyDown, so the same hand that
opened it can put it away. It cannot cancel itself at creation: Ctrl is already held before
the right-click that makes the box, so the keydown fires while nothing is open.
**Follow mode, default Anchor.** A PillToggle in App Settings ("Follow the box"), persisted
as Zoom.FollowBox. Off — the default — keeps the 2026-10-08 model: the capture stays on the
clicked point and dragging only moves the box over it. On, UpdateZoomMove re-anchors the
capture to the box centre (half the box's size, clamped per axis), so the magnifier shows
whatever it hovers. Flipping to Follow while the box is open snaps it immediately.
Three tests: anchor drags leave CaptureX alone, follow moves it to the expected quarter-offset
centre, and the setting round-trips through LayoutStore (tested against the store, not via two
view models — two live VMs fight over the temp DB, which is a fixture problem, not a bug).
Both new test classes share a collection tag: MainViewModel.LayoutPathOverride is static, and
xUnit runs classes in parallel, so without it the two view models collided (one failure in a
combined run, clean when run apart).
Release build 0 warnings; 14 tests pass across zoom, entitlement and preview history. Debug
build is blocked by the running app (PID 47388) — close it and the exe updates.
Creator report: Ctrl+right in edit mode and left-click in preview did nothing when
neither streaming nor recording. The bindings were correct; the action was not.
Two causes, both in the model rather than the handler:
- ActivateZoom opened with `if (!(IsLive || IsRecording)) return;` — the box could not be
created outside a session at all.
- ToggleZoom only ever called DismissZoom, so "toggle" could turn it off and never on.
Now ToggleZoom(x, y) activates at the cursor or dismisses if already open, and the live-only
guard is gone — the magnifier is an editing aid as much as a live one. Both call sites pass
the canvas point, so the box still anchors on the click rather than the frame centre.
Debug 0 warnings; ZoomBox + ZoomMagnifier tests pass (3).
Two event-pairing bugs found by validating every handler instead of trusting the table.
1. Ctrl+right-click opened the context menu in edit mode. Cause: WPF's PopupControlService
opens menus on right-button-UP, and only the DOWN event was being handled — so the zoom
toggled and the menu appeared under it. Both events are now handled when Ctrl is down.
(The creator saw this in edit mode; preview mode had the same latent bug.)
2. The social bar's left-click was dead in preview mode and dragged the layer beneath it in
edit mode. Cause: PreviewGrid handles the TUNNELLING PreviewMouseLeftButtonDown, which
fires before the bar's bubbling handler — and since preview-mode left-click now toggles
zoom, that handler swallowed the bar's click too. The preview handler now steps aside when
the point is inside the bar's bounds (SocialBarElement.RenderSize, translated to canvas).
Audited and left alone because they are correct: left-down → resize handle / element drag /
deselect; move → zoom drag before edit drag (by design); left-up → EndPreviewDrag; right-up
→ zoom-drag release then the Ctrl swallow.
Build Debug 0 warnings, 22 tests pass across ZoomBox, PreviewHistory and SocialBar.
The first half of surge day 1. One question, "may this session emit Pro output?", with
one method on the interface so nothing downstream knows which rail proved it.
SteamEntitlement reads the lifetime SKU the way Valve intends: SteamAPI.Init() then
SteamApps.BIsDlcInstalled(dlcAppId). Four different failure paths all resolve to the
free tier rather than to Pro or to a crash — no DLC id configured, no Steam client,
steam_api64.dll missing (a throw on first touch), and simply not owned. A copied folder
run without Steam is the common case, not an exceptional one.
NotConfigured() is the shipping default until Steamworks creates the DLC app; it answers
false without ever touching the native library, so today's builds behave exactly as they
did before this commit.
HasProOutput is now IsPremium || DeveloperMode || rail, with an internal EntitlementOverride
test seam (internal, because a public setter here is a licence bypass). Four tests: no id
reads false, no client reads false without throwing, the fake reports what a test sets, and
the view model takes its answer from the rail.
Steamworks.NET 2024.8.0 added; the native DLL still comes from scripts/steam-sdk.sh, so the
csproj change is three lines and no formatting churn.
Creator ruling 2026-11-01, and the reason is live-stream ergonomics: no two-handed
chords while a broadcast or recording is running.
- Edit mode: left selects / drags / resizes, right opens the context menu, Ctrl+right
toggles the zoom box. Chords are acceptable here because editing is a stopped activity.
- Preview mode: left toggles the zoom box, right opens the context menu, and Ctrl+right
is swallowed outright — handled rather than left to fall through, so Ctrl+right cannot
open a menu by accident while one hand is on the mouse.
This also removes the old live behaviour where right-click activated the magnifier at the
cursor point (and dismissed it). Zoom in preview is now a plain toggle; if point-zoom is
wanted back it needs a one-button gesture, not a chord.
Build: Release 0 warnings. Debug is currently blocked by the running app holding the exe
(PID 47252) — close it and the Debug build copies normally.
Three creator directives (2026-11-01), done ahead of the surge.
**Gear moved to the preview rail** — first tab, orange (Brush.Attention), gear icon
only. Left-click opens the same app menu the top bar gear owned (Settings / Bug /
Feature / About), right-click goes straight to App Settings; both behaviours moved
with it, so nothing lost an entry point. TopBar keeps the wordmark and EDIT.
**EDIT right edge aligned to the layers panel.** The work area is margin 8 + a 360px
column, the top bar is padding 16, so the shared edge is 352 inside the bar. TopBar
column 0 is now a fixed 352 grid with EDIT right-aligned in it — alignment by
arithmetic instead of by eye.
**Preview undo/redo: Ctrl+Z / Ctrl+Shift+Z.** Models/PreviewHistory snapshots element
REFERENCES plus geometry, visibility, order and membership — a deep clone would mirror
every property of a dozen element subclasses and quietly miss the next one added.
One snapshot per gesture (pushed at drag/resize start, never in the move loop), bounded
at 50, redo survives multiple undos, cleared on layout load. Gated on EditingActive:
undo while the preview shows program output would rewrite a scene nobody is looking at.
Honest scope, in the type's doc comment: layout edits only. Colour/opacity/border/font
edits are not captured yet, so Ctrl+Z after one of those restores the last layout change.
6 tests in PreviewHistoryTests; 19 pass across it and the neighbouring UI classes; Debug
and Release both build at 0 warnings.
Correcting my own plan: the surge is six calendar days (Mon 2 - Sat 7), Saturday included,
and it finishes the coding side. Every open row is assigned to a day; the week-2 and
after-launch sections are gone because there are no such sections.
Days: licensing (entitlement, licence UI, greyed tiers, system messages), release blockers
(visibility picker, output contract, webcam identity, Move transitions), resilience (TASK 32,
bandwidth step-down), content and media (text layer, media wiring, profanity filter,
scheduled streams), data and settings (reward persistence, YPP slice 2, defaults split,
scene audio, settings round, disk hygiene), finish and prove (publish recording, undo, gold
pass, full sweep).
Target 6-8 units a day against a measured baseline of 3-5 — that gap is the surge. If a day
overruns, the smallest item moves; a launch blocker never does. Day 6 is the only polish day.
Non-coding is parked on Valve (identity verification, store page, depot); the week is code,
tests, debugging, polish. Ordered by what actually blocks a public build: entitlement seam
and licence UI (days 1-2), greyed tiers (2), visibility picker (3), stream resilience (3-4),
output contract (4), gold pass (5).
Sized honestly against the measured rate: ~50 units remain, 15-25 fit in five days, so the
plan names week-2 candidates and the five items that should not block launch at all
(scheduled streams, scene audio, defaults split, YPP slice 2, feedback batch).
Every unit carries the same definition of done — clean build, per-class tests, verify.sh on
the declared scope, and the falsified doc corrected in the same commit.
The partner dashboard offers exactly one download because there is only one: the SDK zip
carries the runtime (steam_api64.dll) and the release tooling (sdk/tools/ContentBuilder
with steamcmd.exe for Windows and steamcmd.sh for Linux/macOS, plus the app_build and
depot_build VDF templates). Verified against the zip rather than assumed.
scripts/steam-sdk.sh gains --contentbuilder, opt-in because it is 27 MB of binaries that
only the uploading machine needs.
Distribution.md §2 now opens with that fact — there is no separate ContentBuilder
download to hunt for — plus a reference table of the pages that actually get used:
SteamPipe upload, DLC setup, BIsDlcInstalled, store artwork sizes, Coming Soon window,
the Wallet rule, recurring subs, partner support and Steamworks.NET.
The SDK zip is 24 MB of headers, examples and tools we never build. The runtime
dependency is one native library, so scripts/steam-sdk.sh extracts exactly
sdk/redistributable_bin/win64/steam_api64.dll into steam/ (gitignored, like ffmpeg/ —
the script is the audit trail) and writes steam_appid.txt = 480, Valve's Spacewar app,
so SteamAPI.Init() resolves an app id locally before LlamaCasty has one of its own.
Two csproj details that would have cost a debugging session:
- Link="steam_api64.dll" puts it BESIDE the exe; without Link, None items keep their
relative path and it lands in steam/, where the loader does not look.
- ExcludeFromSingleFile, for the same reason ffmpeg needed it: a native DLL otherwise
gets swallowed into the single-file bundle and cannot be loaded at runtime.
steam_appid.txt is Debug-only — Valve's guidance is not to ship it — and the publish
output confirms it: dll present at the root, no appid file, exe still 127 MB (proof the
DLL was not bundled).
Also queued, as asked: preview undo (Ctrl+Z / Ctrl+Shift+Z) in edit mode, noted as the
partner to the defaults-vs-current split — undo covers the slip, defaults cover the mess.
The paid delta is output quality, so the rule needs to be measurable rather than a word:
921,600 pixels and 30 fps, fail-closed. Models/OutputProfile.cs is that rule as pure
policy — a permitted tier passes through untouched (Pro, or the free tier's own 720p30),
a disallowed one resolves to the best tier the budget allows and carries ITS bitrate, so
a capped user is never offered an 8 Mbps budget for a 720p frame.
Applied once, in BuildEncoderOptions. That is genuinely one place: the stream and the
local recording are two output blocks of ONE ffmpeg process fed by one EncoderOptions,
so there is no second encoder to forget. (commercial.md claimed "both encoders — never
two checks"; the code is stronger than the doc, and the doc is corrected.)
Developer override, as asked: a "Developer mode — all resolutions" checkbox in App
Settings, bound to MainViewModel.DeveloperMode, which feeds HasProOutput. It is not
hidden in a release build — Controls/DeveloperPanel's Page and Compile items are removed
when Configuration != Debug, and OverlayHost adds it at runtime inside #if DEBUG, so a
shipped exe has no BAML for it at all. The setter also refuses the value when
DevBuild.IsDevelopment is false, which is now the single source for that question (the
scoreboard partial had its own duplicate const).
Two traps worth their lines: a `const bool` dev flag makes `if (!Flag) return;` an
unreachable-code warning in one configuration or the other (CS0162), so DevBuild uses
static readonly; and a Condition on an ItemGroup is invisible to a test reading
item.Attribute("Condition") — read the parent.
Tests: 14 pass across OutputProfileTests, AssemblyIdentityTests and StorePackagingTests.
The invariant test is the one that matters: iterate every shipped tier under a free
entitlement and assert none emits more than the budget, so a future 4K tier fails here
instead of shipping to everyone. App builds Debug and Release at 0 warnings.
Renames AssemblyName to LlamaCasty before the first Steam depot — Steamworks is explicit
that renaming a live exe is painful, so this had to land first, not later.
Four assembly-qualified pack URIs carried the old name, not three: MainWindow (window
icon), OverlayHost (logo), RenameRecordingDialog and KeepBroadcastDialog. Pack URIs
resolve by assembly name at runtime, so a stale one compiles, passes every test and then
silently renders nothing the first time that view opens. AssemblyIdentityTests guards
both halves — the assembly name, and no source XAML still naming the legacy assembly.
Packaging/Package.appxmanifest and package-msix.sh carry the exe name too.
scripts/publish.sh replaces the by-hand publish: single-file win-x64, ReadyToRun,
ffmpeg beside the exe, and it refuses to finish if ffmpeg, LICENSE, PRIVACY.md or
THIRD-PARTY-NOTICES.txt are missing, or if a test assembly leaked in.
That last guard exists because the first publish was wrong in a way no test could see:
PublishSingleFile + IncludeNativeLibrariesForSelfExtract bundled the libav*.dll family
into the exe — a 9-file output with no ffmpeg folder and a 182 MB binary, so the locator
would have found nothing at runtime. ExcludeFromSingleFile="true" on the content keeps
the folder a folder. Diffing against a control publish without the single-file flags
found it; guessing at item globs wasted two attempts first (recorded in MyMistakes.md).
Measured: 127 MB exe + 129 MB ffmpeg = 257 MB depot. Tests: AssemblyIdentity,
StorePackaging, BuildStamp, BundledFonts all pass; app builds with 0 warnings.
The site said "Coming soon to Steam" while the app docs still said direct download plus
winget primary with Steam parked. One of them had to move, and the creator's ruling is
Steam exclusive: a free app on Steam with the paid edition as a Steam DLC, and the
$10/month plan sold off-Steam by Polar.
Records the constraint that shapes the code, not just the prose:
- Steamworks requires in-app purchases to use the Steam Wallet (Microtransactions doc,
quoted in commercial.md), so the monthly is *stated*, never *sold*, inside a Steam
build; the lifetime is plain DLC bought on the store page and read with BIsDlcInstalled.
- Entitlement is `steamDlcOwned || polarKeyValid`, both resolving to one OutputProfile.
steam_api64.dll ships beside the exe and is a functional dependency, not the rejected
"IP protection" native DLL — without it DLC ownership cannot be read. Launched without
Steam, the app falls back to the free profile rather than refusing to start.
- Signing is moot: Steam installs never meet SmartScreen. Artifact Signing stays on the
shelf for the day a non-Steam download exists. Year-one fixed cost is ~$115.
- The exe rename must land before the first depot upload — Steamworks warns about
renaming a live exe.
Distribution.md is rewritten to SteamPipe mechanics (publish output, depot, steamcmd,
DLC wiring, clean-account purchase/refund test). product.md, decisions.md (a new
"Steam exclusive" entry with every dead vector), TASKS.md (Steamworks entitlement row,
Steam packaging row), ai.md, index.md and the TASK 48 banner follow. MyMistakes.md gains
the Steam rules that cost real time today: installs skip SmartScreen, updates are free,
the Wallet rule, and the recurring-billing caveat.
Four things derived this session superseded what the plan said twenty-four hours earlier,
and the docs are corrected where each one died:
**Licensing needs no server.** Polar's customer-portal endpoints authenticate on the key
itself plus the public organization_id; the org access token is only needed to create
products. Channel binding rides in `conditions: {channel_id}`, re-checked on every
validate — so the "claim page" (a hosted OAuth flow that wrote the UC id onto the key)
and the key database it implied are deleted. Device management, key rotation and
subscription auto-revocation are Polar's; four states, one lease, no callback endpoint.
**Signing is deferred until two subscribers.** It never removes the day-one SmartScreen
warning (EV's instant-bypass died in 2024), so buying it before revenue buys only the
publisher line. Renamed to Azure Artifact Signing, $9.99/mo Basic, and it requires a
paid Azure subscription. Year-one fixed cost drops from ~$135 to ~$15.
**The Store account is free.** Microsoft waived the $19 individual fee and removed the
$99 company fee in May 2026, which makes the Store the only zero-cost route to a
Microsoft-signed install — the free answer to SmartScreen, noted beside the paid one.
**Support is a filter, not a promise.** Email, best effort, no SLA, refunds on request
without argument; no training service, no helpdesk. A repeated question becomes a
training video on @llamacasty, which is content and monetization instead of a ticket.
GitHub issues on the releases repo are the deliberate friction.
Also settled: binaries live in a second Gitea repo (`llamacasty-releases`) push-mirrored
to a public GitHub repo — issues and assets public, code private, one publish direction
(a git mirror carries refs, not GitHub Release assets); `@llamacasty` is
standard-verified with intermediate features, so live streaming, >15 min uploads and
custom thumbnails work today and no SIM or ID is needed; and OAuth comes out of Testing
mode by publishing the app (100-user lifetime cap, no 7-day token death).
TASKS.md now opens with the four-day surge slice — artifact shape, output gate,
entitlement seam, real-machine day — because those are what the first public release
waits on. HANDOFF.md rewritten. MyMistakes.md gains the Polar recipe and the
"verify means three different things" entry. MARCOM.md gains the support→content loop
and the surface roles.
www.llamacasty.com now resolves and 301s to the apex. Four traps worth keeping:
yunohost domain add --install-letsencrypt-cert exits SUCCESS with only a self-signed
cert (it skips LE when the parent has no wildcard), plain cert install then insists on
a diagnosis and needs --no-checks, a domain with no app 302s to the YunoHost SSO rather
than 404ing, and writing the nginx snippet over ssh with an unquoted heredoc silently
expands $request_uri to nothing — every path then redirects to the homepage. Also
recorded: both resolvers near this job lie about the name (workstation NXDOMAIN cache,
droplet dnsmasq answering ::1).
The commercial plan was spread over five documents written in five different weeks,
and they contradicted each other: product.md sold the Store, decisions.md called the
Store dead then re-opened, Distribution.md (736 lines) still described Polar as a
download host, MARCOM.md quoted "no subscription" next to a paid tier, and README.md
promised "free forever". An outsider could not tell what ships.
docs/ai/commercial.md is now the only place money is decided: free = whole app at a
921,600 px / 30 fps output profile covering the recording as well as the stream; Pro =
$10/mo or $400 lifetime through Polar, key bound to the buyer's YouTube channel ID via
a claim page, 2 activations, 7–14 day lease with offline grace, fail closed, never
downgrade a running stream; one portable zip + winget primary, Steam and the Store
parked; Azure Trusted Signing (~$9.99/mo), no EV; Founding 200 promo; ~$135/yr costs;
anti-piracy posture and what is permanently rejected.
Everything else now points at it instead of restating it:
- product.md — money sections replaced with pointers; packaging rewritten to
winget-first, Store parked; signing updated to Trusted Signing.
- decisions.md — graveyard with cause of death for free-forever, the Store ordering,
the updater, and the 2026-10-30 reversal of the quality-ceiling rejection.
- Distribution.md — rewritten to release mechanics only (artifact, GitHub Releases,
winget manifest, signing, checklist, takedown): 736 → 120 lines.
- TASKS.md — TASK 54 rewritten, TASK 48's route settled, TASK 10 superseded, five new
rows (entitlement seam, output-profile gate, licence UI, system messages, packaging).
- README.md — "free forever" replaced with the real split.
- capture.md — obs-backgroundremoval is GPL-3.0 and so licence-INCOMPATIBLE since the
proprietary EULA; the old "compatible" line was falsified by that change.
- TASKS/task-10, task-48, task-51, task-54 — superseded-banner at the top of each, so
none of them reads as current policy.
- HANDOFF.md — rewritten: plan settled, next code unit is the entitlement seam.
MARCOM.md and MONETIZATION.md (gitignored) were corrected in place: policy pointer at
the top of each, the flash removed from every live claim, the Polar fee break-even
corrected to ~$900/mo, and the projections flagged as written against a dead model.
Deploying the site cost a session because the only documentation was a destination
('/var/www/linkstack/'), not a transport, and the failure modes looked like credential
problems rather than the two things they were: sshd offers publickey only on 2214, and
it appended a keyboard-interactive 2FA step that a non-interactive tool call cannot
answer (hang, then 'Permission denied (publickey)').
Records the whole shape: web root and owner, port 2214 key-only, password = sudo not
SSH, the 2026-10-30 removal of AuthenticationMethods/PAM 2FA, and the traps — the md
files must never be published (build-this.md now carries INTERNAL pricing), drvfs 777
needs the chmod pass, linkstack__2 is a different app, and 22/1319 are closed.
Recipe lives in llamacasty.web/deploy.sh.
Records the split so neither side drifts: the app repo holds the real numbers (720p30 free, $10/mo
or $400 lifetime, Store individual account) and the site holds only the promise (free forever, every
feature unlocked, a paid edition at launch).
Creator ruling 2026-10-30: the Microsoft Store is the distribution target again, through an
Individual (not Company) developer account — which is what made the 2026-10-22 withdrawal necessary
in the first place, and why no legal entity is now required. The publisher line shows the verified
individual name; distribution work stays parked until the account exists, and the site's 'coming
soon to the Microsoft Store' copy is accurate again.
Licensing posture changes to closed-source commercial software (creator ruling 2026-10-30): free
tier caps output at 720p30, a paid licence unlocks 1080p ($10/month or $400 lifetime).
- LICENSE is now an End User License Agreement: grant, what you may do with your own content,
no redistribution/reverse engineering, third-party components prevail, updates at publisher
discretion, warranty and liability limits, termination, governing law.
- ADDITIONAL-TERMS.md deleted — those were GPL §7 terms and have no meaning under the EULA.
- THIRD-PARTY-NOTICES.txt keeps every third-party obligation and drops the GPL header and §6
source offer; it states plainly that LlamaCasty ships no source.
- PRIVACY.md is new: exactly what is written locally (layout DB, DPAPI token, capped log,
recordings you choose), what leaves the machine (Google's APIs only, with your account), and the
standing promises (chat rendered never stored, no telemetry, no ad SDKs).
- README, docs/ai/product.md, docs/ai/decisions.md and TASKS.md record the decision and the
obligations that still bind (ffmpeg LGPL as a separate process, OFL fonts, CC0 icons, model
provenance, notices in the About screen).
Deliberately NOT decided here: key issuance/verification and the resolution gate itself. Earlier
GPL builds remain GPL for the versions that shipped under it.
Two controls looked dead because new ScoreboardStyle() zero-initialised instead of applying the
declaration's defaults. Recorded with the rule (explicit parameterless ctor) and the testing lesson
(a defaults test must construct with new(), not with explicit arguments).
Creator's defaults: white text, Background ON (black, 20%), speed capped at 200 px/s, text size shown
in real pixels, and "plate" dropped from the label.
The important find is underneath those: `ScoreboardStyle` is a record STRUCT, and `new
ScoreboardStyle()` zero-initialises — it does NOT run the constructor's parameter defaults. So the
shipped strip had null text colour, NO background and zero opacity, whatever the source said. That is
why the Background checkbox and the opacity slider looked like they had no code behind them: the
renderer was faithfully drawing the zeros it was handed.
An explicit parameterless constructor now carries the real defaults, and the renderer test asserts
them (white / on / black / 0.20 / max speed 200) so this class of silent-zero cannot return.
Readouts fixed too: the opacity and text-size setters never raised their own property, so the numbers
never moved while the render did. Text size now reads "24 px" instead of a bare slider value, and
snaps to whole pixels.
The marquee now has the dial it needs. `ScoreboardPresenter.PixelsPerSecond` is the single owner of
the range (20-400, default 120), the layer's properties expose it with a live px/s readout, and the
value is persisted as Scoreboard.ScrollSpeed because it is a READABILITY choice — re-dialling it
every launch would be a tax on the creator who needs the strip to be readable.
Advance() still takes an optional override so tests can drive exact distances.
Guard: the presenter test proves speed is real (same elapsed time, twice the speed, different
window) — not a value that is stored and ignored — and the panel test pins the control, its range
and the persistence key.
Creator, plainly: "the entire point of a ticker is to tick… so, tick." The static strip was my
reading of an earlier exchange; it is gone.
How it ticks without becoming the compositor's most expensive layer:
- `ScoreboardRenderer.RenderRun` rasterises the run ONCE per value change at its natural width plus
a gap.
- `ScoreboardPresenter` crops a 1920-wide window at a moving offset each tick — a row-wise byte
copy, no text layout, no re-raster.
- `TickScoreboard` runs on the existing 30 Hz meter clock and only while the strip is shown, so a
hidden or disabled scoreboard costs nothing.
The dev simulation uses the same path, so what is previewed is what ships.
Test updated to the real contract: no tick → identical pixels; a tick → different pixels; a value
change → re-rasterised run. (The old test asserted frame-instance identity, which a cropped window
can never satisfy.)
Reported: the ticker was painting OVER the socials. The coupling rule existed and was tested
(ScoreboardLayout.ResolveEdges) but nothing ever CALLED it — the strip's Y still came from its own
preference, so both bars landed on the south edge.
Now the resolution runs at publish time: the social bar keeps its side, the scoreboard takes the
other one, and its Y follows from that edge. The pair re-sorts whenever the social bar moves (the
preview click-toggle) or shows/hides, because the rule is "resolve from what is visible", not a
stored pairing.
The layer also gains an Edge preference (Top/Bottom) in its properties, labelled "socials take the
other" — a preference, never a claim on an occupied edge.
Also stabilised the opacity assertion: it samples a plate-only pixel 5px from the left edge instead
of the first semi-transparent pixel it finds (which could be anti-aliased text).
Four reports, three causes:
1. "Background plate has no code behind it" — the plate COLOUR and OPACITY controls were disabled
until the plate switch was on, which reads as dead controls. They are always settable now; the
switch is what decides whether a plate is drawn.
2. "Opacity doesn't work" — proven in the renderer test: 20% and 80% produce alphas of ~51 and ~204,
so the slider reaches the pixels. What was actually wrong was the box.
3. The strip's BOX was fixed at 56px while a wrapped strip renders taller — the frame was scaled
into the box and looked squashed/clipped. The source's width/height now follow the rendered
frame, and its Y follows from the edge.
4. "Simulate (dev) should override Show the scoreboard" — it does: the preview gate is
(_scoreboardEnabled || _scoreboardSimulate), so the dev toggle works even with the product
setting off.
Not changed: the strip is STATIC by design (all enabled facts always visible, wrap rather than
scroll). If scrolling is wanted after all, that is a presentation mode to add, not a fix.
"Clicking on everything produces no visible effect" — the cause was upstream of the controls, and it
is the same defect as the invisible alert box (TASK 47):
- `Source.DisplaySource` returned `VideoImageSource` only for ChatBox / WebSource / MediaSource /
AlertBox. The scoreboard's frame was rendered and published, then never displayed.
- the preview's Image has a per-type Visibility trigger for each of those and none for IsScoreboard,
so even a correct DisplaySource would have stayed collapsed.
Both are fixed, and the layer test now pins the frame-source list AND the trigger so the pair cannot
drift apart again.
Dev-only affordances are ORANGE from now on (creator ruling): "Simulate (dev)" is a TextBlock in
Brush.Attention, so a development control can never be mistaken for product. The panel test pins the
colour.
Creator (2026-10-30): in dev mode the "Show the scoreboard" option must always be available.
The block's gate becomes CanUseScoreboard = IsConnected || IsDevelopmentBuild. Signed-out Release
still shows the inert block with its "sign in" line; a DEBUG build is fully usable, so the strip can
be toggled and previewed before there is an account. IsConnected raises it, so signing in flips it
live.
Guard: ScoreboardPropertiesTests now asserts the CanUseScoreboard gate (enabled AND hint), and the
VM surface list includes it.
Creator (2026-10-30): pre-1.0, use DEBUG — add a toggle that simulates the ticker so the strip can
be SEEN and its compositing verified before a real stream.
The sample travels the REAL ScoreboardRecorder a stream uses (one new member, a gift of three, a
milestone, a $12.34 Super Chat), so what the preview shows is exactly what live events produce — a
fake renderer would prove nothing. Toggling off clears to an empty session, so the empty state is
visible too.
Debug-gated at COMPILE time: `DevelopmentBuild` is a const true in DEBUG / false in Release, and the
checkbox binds its Visibility to it. A shipped Release build therefore has no dev control at all,
rather than one hidden by a runtime flag.
Guard: ScoreboardSimulationTests — the sample lands all four tallies through the recorder, off clears,
and the panel + const pair exist in the Dual (DEBUG/Release) form.
The scoreboard is fed by the signed-in channel (chat events + channel stats), so offering its
switches to a signed-out user is a dead control. The whole block now binds IsEnabled to IsConnected
and shows one line — "Sign in to YouTube to use the scoreboard." — instead of looking broken.
Nothing extra is needed to re-enable: IsConnected already raises on sign-in/out, so the block
comes alive the moment the session lands.
Guard: ScoreboardPropertiesTests asserts the IsEnabled binding, the signed-out hint and that the
hint is gated by the inverse converter.
Creator: "even if it's not visible, we want to avoid polling."
ScoreboardEnabled is the layer's master switch in the properties panel. Off means two things:
- the strip frame is null in every scene (per-scene eye toggles stay independent), and
- the cadence policy returns None at every phase — a scoreboard nobody can see must not spend quota.
The switch is persisted (Scoreboard.Enabled), because one that resets would quietly resume polling.
The polling gate is ScoreboardPollsEnabled: master switch AND at least one scene with a visible
scoreboard — so hiding it in all five scenes also stops the polls.
Guards: ScoreboardCadenceTests adds the switch off across live/test/recording; ScoreboardProperties
pins the checkbox and the VM surface.
Creator ruling: the Scoreboard layer exists in every scene rather than being added five times.
ScoreboardHealer.Ensure keeps exactly one per scene — healed on load like the Background and Brand
logo — so a scene can never end up with two, and 'off' is the ordinary per-scene eye toggle rather
than a delete.
It is appended as the TOPMOST layer on purpose: a full-width strip draws over the scene, and
inserting it above the background would break the Brand logo's documented invariant (directly above
the background). That choice is also why the layer-reorder test still passes untouched.
Also: a layer-list icon for the type, so the row is not blank.
Guard: ScoreboardHealerTests — one per scene, topmost, exact strip geometry, idempotent, and a
duplicate healed back to one.
Both were mine, from the scoreboard units:
- ScoreboardLayout.FitLine null-forgave tileWidths on one expression and then iterated the field
anyway; it now binds a non-null local once and uses that throughout.
- the output resolver dereferenced _scoreboardPresenter, which is assigned in InitScoreboard — it
is nullable by construction, so the resolver reads '?.' exactly like the other optional services.
Clean build, 0 warnings, scoreboard tests green.
ScoreboardCadence.Due(phase, lastAnalytics, lastSubscribers, now) is the creator's rule as a pure
function: watch hours ONLY during a live stream, every 30 minutes (Analytics answers in days and
test/record sessions have no public audience, so querying then is pure waste); subscribers whenever
the app is working, every 60 s; and nothing at all when idle.
Deliberately returns 'no poll' rather than 'analytics only' — a poll kind the poller cannot perform
is a bug waiting for a caller.
Remaining for the scoreboard: the HTTP providers behind this policy (watch hours via Analytics
reports.query, subscribers via channels.list) and the timer that calls Due(). Recorded in HANDOFF.
Scope becomes youtube + yt-analytics.readonly, with include_granted_scopes=true so an existing
session is asked for the NEW permission only. GrantedScopes records what Google says on the token
response (both the code exchange and the refresh), and HasAnalyticsScope is the flag the scoreboard
uses to offer a one-click re-consent instead of failing anonymously mid-stream.
TokenStore is unchanged on purpose: a launch-time refresh carries the scope list, so old sessions
report 'not granted' until the creator re-consents — the honest state.
The old auth test asserted 'exactly one scope'; it now asserts the new DECISION (two scopes, no
force-ssl, analytics read-only) rather than loosening.
Unit 6 created the recorder and the session hook but nothing fed it — the strip would have stayed
empty through a whole stream. The poll's message handler now records each decoded event after the
chat and alert layers have seen it.
Caught by tracing the data path while wiring analytics, not by a test: the guards cover the tally
rules, not the seam into the poller.
Selecting a Scoreboard layer now shows its settings, using the app's own widgets only:
- eight fact checkboxes (subscribers, watch hours, Super Chats, new members, milestones, last member,
last Super Chat, last gift)
- text colour and plate colour via YtComboBox over BorderColorPalette (the app's one palette —
TASK 63's rule: a picker IS the app's drop-down, never a hand-built menu)
- plate on/off, plate opacity, text size 14-24
Every change pushes through the presenter (SetStyle/SetTiles) and repaints the strip, so the preview
and the output follow immediately. One look per layout, stored on the view-model: the scoreboard is a
single billboard, not eight independent widgets.
Guard: ScoreboardPropertiesTests asserts the panel is gated on SelectedElement.IsScoreboard, binds
all eight facts and the four look controls, uses YtComboBox/YtCheckBox only, and that the VM surface
exists for each name (a typo would otherwise bind to nothing in silence).
Adds SourceType.Scoreboard with the same per-scene eye toggle, drag and presence as every other
element — 'prominent on BRB, dialled back on Live' is geometry, not a second mechanism. Default
geometry is the strip: 1920 wide, 56 tall, bottom edge.
The output resolver returns the presenter's cached frame exactly like the chat box and alert box do,
and every session start clears the tallies. Preview publication writes one shared WriteableBitmap on
the UI thread (the pump thread must never touch one), refreshed only when a displayed value moves.
Guard: ScoreboardLayerTests pins the enum member, the geometry constants, the resolver case and the
session hook, so the layer cannot quietly become a special widget.
ScoreboardTiles decides which of the eight facts appear and shapes their text (money uses the
session's dominant currency and flags a second one rather than converting; watch hours carry
'as of {date}' because Analytics is a daily aggregate). Tiles are OPT-IN, so 'None' really means the
layer draws nothing, and 'Default' is the six session facts.
ScoreboardPresenter owns the raster cache: ScoreboardRecorder.Changed fires only on a visible change,
so the strip rebuilds only then — a per-tick raster would be the compositor's most expensive layer
for identical pixels.
Guard: ScoreboardPresenterTests asserts the cache identity (same instance when nothing moved, a new
frame when a value moved, reuse when a recipient-side gift event arrives) and that an empty selection
returns no frame at all.
Rasterises enabled tiles into one straight-alpha BGRA frame: measured widths -> FitLine (shrink,
then wrap, never scroll) -> centred lines with dim separators, over an optional rounded plate whose
colour and opacity are the creator's knobs. Uses OutputPalette.Sans (bundled Inter) because on-stream
text wears the app's typefaces.
Static by design: it takes plain strings, so the caller caches the frame and only re-rasterises when
a value changes — a strip that re-rendered every tick would be the compositor's most expensive layer
for no benefit.
Guard: ScoreboardRendererTests paints real frames and inspects pixels — plate colour AND opacity,
text colour reaching glyphs, plate-off leaves the area transparent, and an empty tile set returns no
frame at all.
ResolveEdges: the strip and the social bar are a coupled pair that own opposite edges whenever both
are visible; the social bar keeps its choice and the scoreboard is pushed to the other edge. Hide
either and the survivor keeps its own preference — so hiding the scoreboard frees the social bar,
which is what 'resolved at render time' has to mean.
FitLine: takes MEASURED tile widths (the renderer measures with FormattedText; a guessed character
width would make the fit lie for a long handle), keeps full size when it fits, shrinks above the
14px legibility floor, and only then wraps — never scrolls, because a reader cannot wait for the
fact to come round.
ScoreboardRecorder owns the one scope the numbers promise. StartSession resets and marks running;
Record ignores everything outside a session (a stale tally from the last stream is exactly the
'today' lie this design avoids); EndSession freezes the numbers but stops them moving, so an End
screen can still show them. Changed fires only when a displayed value actually moves, which is what
keeps the strip's raster cache honest.
gramps